This pear almond French toast casserole is the kind of breakfast that makes me want to sit down and actually take my time with it. Buttery brioche bakes in a creamy vanilla-almond custard, with thin pear slices tucked between the bread and toasted almonds scattered over the top. The edges get a little crisp, the middle stays soft, and each serving has 29 grams of protein.

I wanted a cozy fall breakfast that gave the pumpkin a little break, and this pear French toast bake was exactly where I landed. The fruit softens in the oven while the almond extract gives the custard that sweet, bakery-style flavor. Add the crunch on top and suddenly I’m making sure every forkful has a little of everything.
The best part about a brioche French toast casserole is getting those buttery, golden edges without standing at the stove flipping individual pieces. I keep the bread in smaller slices and arrange them upright, so the custard settles around the base while the tops peek out. It looks a little fancy, but the assembly is mostly whisking, pouring, and tucking in the fruit.
Greek yogurt, eggs, egg whites, and vanilla protein powder make this a high protein French toast casserole that still feels like a slow weekend breakfast. The batch makes three servings, which is a nice middle ground when I want a small brunch bake and a portion left over. A dusting of powdered sugar and a drizzle of syrup are optional, but they do make that first bite feel extra cozy.
Macros Per Serving
409 Cal | 44g Carbs | 13g Fat | 29g Protein
Why You’ll Love This Recipe
There’s a lot to love about a breakfast with a soft center and just enough crunch on top. This pear almond French toast casserole brings those textures together in a small batch that makes three satisfying servings.
- Soft, custardy bread: The brioche soaks up the vanilla-almond mixture while the exposed edges develop a little golden crispness.
- A little crunch in every serving: Sliced almonds go on during the final five minutes, giving them a chance to toast without spending the entire bake in the oven.
- Protein built into the custard: Greek yogurt, whole eggs, egg whites, and vanilla protein powder contribute to the 29 grams per serving.
- Simple assembly: A pear French toast bake starts with a quick custard; whisk it, arrange the bread, pour, and tuck in the fruit before the oven takes over.
- A small brunch batch: Three servings make this easy to share without committing to a huge pan.
I love that baked French toast with pears can feel special with such a straightforward ingredient list. Serve it warm and get a little fruit, custard, and almond crunch on your fork.

Key Ingredients for this Pear Almond French Toast Casserole
The ingredients here each bring something useful to the bake, from the rich bread to that delicate almond flavor. Here’s what gives this pear almond French toast casserole its soft middle and toasted finish.
- Brioche bread: Its buttery flavor and tender crumb give a brioche French toast casserole its rich base, with exposed edges that brown as it bakes.
- Nonfat Greek yogurt: Thick yogurt adds creaminess and protein to the mixture surrounding the bread.
- Eggs: Whole eggs help the custard set and give it richness.
- Liquid egg whites: These add more protein and help the custard hold together without adding more whole eggs.
- Vanilla protein powder: A vanilla-flavored powder sweetens and flavors the custard while contributing protein; different formulas can change the texture.
- Nonfat milk: A small splash loosens the mixture so it pours between the bread slices.
- Almond extract: A little gives the custard a distinct sweet almond aroma without needing a separate filling.
- Pear: Thin slices soften between the pieces of brioche and bring a gentle fruit sweetness.
- Sliced almonds: Added near the end, they give the finished bake its toasted crunch.
- Powdered sugar: An optional light dusting adds a pretty finish and extra sweetness.
- Maple syrup: An optional drizzle brings a little more sweetness to the warm bread and fruit.
Substitution Options
This pear almond French toast casserole was made with the ingredients listed in the recipe card. The ideas below are suggestions for another batch, rather than swaps I’ve tested in this exact bake. For a high protein French toast casserole, changes to the bread or protein powder can affect how much custard is absorbed and how firmly the center sets.
- Bread options: Challah or another soft, thick-sliced bread may work in place of brioche, although the flavor and richness will change. Keep an eye on how it absorbs the custard rather than assuming every loaf behaves the same.
- Milk options: Another dairy milk can replace the nonfat milk for a richer result. An unsweetened plant milk is another possible option, but it changes the nutrition and does not make the whole recipe dairy-free.
- Greek yogurt options: A different fat percentage of plain Greek yogurt may give a richer custard. Regular thin yogurt would change the consistency more noticeably, so I would stay with a thick Greek-style yogurt.
- Extract options: Vanilla extract can take the place of almond extract for a different flavor direction. The result will have less of that distinct almond bakery aroma.
- Almond topping options: Finely chopped pecans could add a different kind of crunch. Add them near the end and watch closely, since smaller pieces can brown quickly.
Keep the eggs and egg whites as written for the most predictable custard. I haven’t tested a version without protein powder, so simply leaving it out may change both sweetness and texture. Any swaps or extra toppings will also change the listed macros.
**If there is a sub I haven’t mentioned above, it’s because I have not tested it and can’t speak for how well it would work for this recipe.
Equipment and Tools
You don’t need much equipment to put this pear almond French toast casserole together. A bowl and whisk handle the custard, and small oven-safe dishes hold the bread in those cozy overlapping layers. Choose dishes that fit the bread without squeezing the pieces so tightly that the custard can’t settle between them.
- Mixing Bowl: Use a bowl with enough room to whisk the yogurt, eggs, and remaining custard ingredients comfortably.
- Whisk: This helps smooth out the yogurt and incorporate the protein powder before pouring.
- Measuring Scale: Weigh the bread, yogurt, egg whites, protein powder, prepared pear, and sliced almonds for portions that match the recipe.
- Measuring Spoon and Liquid Measure: These make it easier to measure the almond extract and milk.
- Knife and Cutting Board: Use these to portion the bread and cut the cored pear into thin slices.
- Small Oven-Safe Baking Dishes: Arrange the bread upright with room for the custard and fruit; dish depth and how tightly the bread is packed can affect baking time.
- Baking Tray: A tray underneath makes small dishes easier to move together and catches any drips.
- Aluminum Foil: A loose tent protects bread that starts browning before the center has finished cooking.
- Toothpick: Check the center for wet custard instead of relying on the color of the tops alone.
The setup for baked French toast with pears stays simple, so you can focus on the texture as it bakes. Keep the foil handy, especially when making this in a toaster oven with limited clearance.
How to Make Your Pear Almond French Toast Casserole
This pear almond French toast casserole comes together with a quick whisked custard and a little arranging in the baking dishes. Keep the bread in slices so some edges sit above the creamy base. The pears go in before baking, while the almonds wait until the final few minutes.

Prep the Bread and Dishes
Preheat your oven to 350°F and lightly grease your small oven-safe baking dishes with olive oil spray. Cut the brioche into smaller pieces that fit the dishes while keeping the sliced shape. Core the pear and slice it thinly so it can tuck between the bread without pushing everything apart.
Whisk a Smooth Custard
Whisk the Greek yogurt with the whole eggs and egg whites, then add the vanilla protein powder, milk, and almond extract. Keep whisking until the mixture looks smooth and pours easily from the bowl. Breaking up any powder pockets now helps the custard bake more evenly around the bread.

Arrange, Pour, and Add the Pear
Arrange the bread upright in slightly overlapping layers. Pour the custard over and around the pieces, dividing it evenly between your dishes. Tuck the pear slices into the gaps and gently press the bread down so it can soak up some of the mixture. You want the custard to reach the bread, with some edges still peeking out above it.
Bake and Finish with Almonds
Bake for about 30 minutes, then scatter the sliced almonds over the top and return the dishes to the oven for about five more minutes. The tested bake took approximately 35 minutes total. Start watching the tops earlier, particularly in a short toaster oven where the bread sits close to the upper heating element.
Loosely tent with foil if the tops are browning too quickly, leaving clearance from the heating elements. Remove the foil for the almonds to toast when possible, watching them closely. Insert a toothpick into the center and check that there is no wet custard clinging to it; the middle should be set rather than liquid, even if the bread on top already looks done.
Portion and Serve
Let the bake settle slightly before dividing it into three servings. Finish with powdered sugar or a drizzle of syrup if you’d like, keeping in mind those optional extras are not included in the listed macros.
That contrast between the soft center and toasted topping is what makes this baked French toast with pears so good straight from the dish. Get a little of each layer onto your fork while it’s still warm.
Tips and Tricks
A few small details make a difference with this pear almond French toast casserole. Give the custard space to soak into the bread, and let the center tell you when it’s done.
- Keep the pear slices thin: Thin pieces tuck neatly between the brioche and soften more evenly during baking.
- Whisk out the powder pockets: Smooth the custard before pouring so you don’t end up with dry bits of protein powder in the finished bake.
- Avoid packing the bread too tightly: A brioche French toast casserole needs room for the custard to travel between the slices instead of pooling around the outside.
- Protect the tops early: My short toaster oven browned some of the exposed bread too much. A loose foil tent helps protect those edges while the middle finishes cooking.
- Save the almonds for last: Add them for the final five minutes, rather than at the beginning, to keep their crunch without over-browning.
- Check the center: A golden top doesn’t guarantee a cooked custard underneath. Use a toothpick and check that the center is set, extending the time as needed.
- Count optional toppings separately: The powdered sugar and syrup shown in the video are finishing options and are not part of the supplied nutrition totals.
Keep those texture cues in mind and this high protein French toast casserole is easy to adjust to your oven. A little patience with the center is worth it.
Storage Instructions
This pear almond French toast casserole makes three servings, so you may have a portion left for another breakfast. Store baked French toast with pears covered in the refrigerator once it has cooled enough to pack away. I haven’t tested a specific storage window for this exact version.
- Keep portions covered: Use an airtight container or cover the baking dish well to help the bread hold onto its moisture.
- Add finishing toppings later: Keep optional syrup and powdered sugar separate until serving so the surface doesn’t become unnecessarily wet.
- Reheat gently: Warm a portion in the microwave in short intervals, or use a covered oven-safe dish in the oven, checking the center as it heats.
- Expect a softer topping: Refrigeration and microwaving can soften the almonds and exposed bread edges.
- Freezer testing: I haven’t tested freezing this recipe, so I can’t promise the same custardy texture after thawing.
Reheat only the portion you plan to eat. Warm it through before adding any optional toppings. For the crispest contrast, enjoy the bake freshly made.

More French Toast Casserole Recipes
I love a cozy breakfast with soft fruit, buttery bread, and something creamy tucked in between. Here are a few more of my recipes to try when you’re in the mood for those same flavors.
FAQs
Here are a few details that help when making this pear almond French toast casserole at home. The biggest things to watch are the custard in the center and the exposed bread on top. Your baking dish and oven can change how quickly each one cooks in a pear French toast bake.
-
Can I make this in a toaster oven?
Yes, this version was baked in a toaster oven, but some of the bread tops browned too much because of the limited clearance. Loosely tent the dish with foil when needed, keeping it away from the heating elements, and check the center rather than judging doneness by the top alone.
-
How do I know when the custard is cooked?
Insert a toothpick into the center and check that it comes out without wet custard clinging to it. The middle should look set rather than liquid, so give it more time if necessary even when the exposed bread is already browned.
-
When should I add the sliced almonds?
Add the almonds after about 30 minutes, then bake for approximately five minutes more. Adding them late gives them a chance to toast without sitting through the full baking time.
-
What makes this a high protein French toast casserole?
Greek yogurt, whole eggs, egg whites, and vanilla protein powder all contribute protein to the custard. Dividing the supplied ingredient totals into three servings gives about 29 grams of protein per serving, before optional finishing toppings.
Recipe Card
Pear Almond French Toast Casserole
Ingredients
French Toast:
- 180 g sliced brioche bread (Trader Joe’s)
- 226 g nonfat Greek yogurt (Fage)
- 2 large eggs (Vital Farms)
- 100 g liquid egg whites (H-E-B)
- 31 g vanilla protein powder (Quest)
- 60 ml nonfat milk (Whole Foods)
- ¼ tsp almond extract
- Olive oil spray (for greasing)
- 80 g pear (cored and thinly sliced)
Topping:
- 14 g sliced almonds (Whole Foods)
- Powdered sugar (optional, to taste)
- Maple syrup (optional, to taste)
Instructions
Prep:
- Preheat the oven to 350°F. Lightly grease small oven-safe baking dishes with olive oil spray.Olive oil spray
- Cut the brioche slices into smaller pieces that fit your dishes, keeping them in slices rather than cubes.180 g (3 slices) sliced brioche bread
Make the Custard:
- Whisk the Greek yogurt, eggs, and egg whites until combined. Add the vanilla protein powder, milk, and almond extract and whisk until smooth.226 g (1 cup) nonfat Greek yogurt, 2 large eggs, 100 g (6.5 tbsp) liquid egg whites, 31 g (1 scoop) vanilla protein powder, 60 ml (0.25 cups) nonfat milk, 1/4 tsp almond extract
Assemble:
- Arrange the brioche pieces upright and slightly overlapping in the prepared dishes. Pour the custard evenly over and around the bread.
- Tuck the pear slices between the brioche pieces. Gently press the bread into the custard so it can absorb the mixture.80 g (0.5 whole) pear
Bake:
- Bake for about 30 minutes, then scatter the sliced almonds over the top and bake for about 5 minutes more, approximately 35 minutes total.14 g (1 tbsp) sliced almonds
- In a short toaster oven or whenever the tops brown too quickly, loosely tent with foil while the center cooks, keeping the foil clear of the heating elements. Uncover for the almonds to toast, watching closely.
- Check the center with a toothpick; it should come out without wet custard, and the center should be set. Continue baking as needed even if the top is already browned.
Serve:
- Let the bake settle slightly, then divide into 3 servings. Finish with optional powdered sugar and maple syrup.Powdered sugar, Maple syrup
Nutrition Information
The Nutrition Facts above are specific to the ingredients I chose to use for this recipe.
Save this recipe to your Pinterest Board and share it with your family and friends!

DID YOU MAKE THIS RECIPE?
Be sure to tag @tishasveggieeats on Instagram and hashtag #tishasveggieeats!














Leave a Reply